The Pain of Benching in Dating: Are You an Option?

Let’s call it the dating dugout. You’re in the game… sort of. But you’re definitely not playing. That feeling hits when their name flashes on your screen, and your stomach does a little nervous flip-flop. The conversation flows. It’s good. Maybe it’s even great. Then, just as you start to think, Okay, this could be something, they pull a disappearing act. Radio silence. Weeks crawl by, and just when you’ve managed to stop compulsively checking your phone, a message pops up. It’s 11 PM. “Hey, you up?” This is benching in dating.

It’s the soul-crushing practice of being kept on the sidelines, just in case their first-string picks don’t work out. And honestly, it’s one of the most maddening parts of trying to find a real connection today.

Being benched feels like a personal attack. It’s a slow, steady chipping away at your self-worth that makes you second-guess everything. Was it something I said? Am I not fun enough? Why won’t they choose me? But here’s the truth: their decision to bench you has almost nothing to do with you. It’s a direct reflection of their own baggage—their indecisiveness, their insecurities, their flat-out inability to communicate like an adult. Still, you’re the one left staring at a blank screen, feeling like a “maybe” when you deserve to be a “hell yes.” It’s time to stop wondering, understand what’s happening, and take back your power.

More in Modern Dating Dilemmas Category

What Is a Situationship

Psychology of Ghosting

Key Takeaways

• What is Benching? It’s being kept as a backup plan. The bencher gives you just enough attention to keep you from moving on but never commits. You’re on the team, but you’re never getting off the sideline.
• It’s Not About You. People bench others because they’re afraid to be alone, need a constant ego boost, or are too cowardly to end things directly. This is their problem, not a reflection of your value.
• Spot the Red Flags. The signs are obvious when you look for them: wildly inconsistent communication, a love for last-minute plans, conversations that are a mile wide and an inch deep, and a habit of vanishing and reappearing without any explanation.
• Get Back in the Game (Your Own). The only way to win is to stop playing. Recognize the behavior, put your own emotional health first, and have the strength to walk away from anyone who treats you like an option.

So, What Exactly Does Benching in Dating Even Mean?

Picture a football team. You’ve got the quarterback and the receivers out on the field, running the plays. Then you’ve got the players on the bench. They’re in uniform, ready to go, but they’re just waiting. Watching. Hoping the coach will finally call their number. That’s you in a benching situation. The person you’re seeing is the coach, and they’ve decided you’re not a starter. Not right now, anyway.

They’ll keep you in the loop, but never in the huddle where decisions are made. A text here, a late-night call there—it’s all carefully calculated to keep your interest piqued. Just enough so you don’t quit the team. But there’s no forward momentum. No real commitment. You’re their safety net, their “what if,” their emergency contact for a lonely Tuesday night. For them, it’s a low-risk, high-reward situation. For you, it’s an emotional prison.

Why Does It Hurt So Much to Be on Someone’s Sideline?

The pain of being benched is a special kind of awful. It’s not the clean, sharp wound of being ghosted. It’s a chronic ache. A constant, humming anxiety fueled by not knowing where you stand. Your heart is stuck on a seesaw of hope and disappointment. One good conversation sends you soaring. Days of silence bring you crashing back down. It’s utterly exhausting.

Worse, it starts to mess with your head. You begin to believe the story they’re telling you with their actions: you are an option. You are second-best. Thoughts that would normally never cross your mind start to take root. What’s wrong with me? Why am I so forgettable? The whole dynamic is designed to make you feel powerless, your happiness hanging on the thread of their next text. You can’t move on, but you can’t move forward either. You’re just… stuck.

But Why Would Someone Do This in the First Place?

Figuring out the “why” can feel impossible, but it’s often the key to breaking free. Benching isn’t usually born from pure evil. It’s a messy mix of someone else’s insecurity, selfishness, and a total failure to communicate. The person benching you is almost certainly fighting their own demons, and you’ve just been pulled into the crossfire.

Are They Afraid of Being Alone?

For a lot of people, the idea of having no one is their worst nightmare. They might not be sold on a future with you, but the alternative—total solitude—is even less appealing. So they keep you on the bench. You become their safety valve for loneliness. Their emotional security blanket. It’s a profoundly selfish move, using your time and feelings to quiet their own fears without offering anything real in return.

Do They Just Want an Ego Boost?

Sometimes, it’s all about them. Knowing they have a roster of people waiting in the wings makes them feel powerful. Desirable. Your attention is the fuel. A quick text from you can be the perfect antidote to a bad day or a rejection from someone they actually wanted to date. I dated a guy who had this down to a science. He’d vanish for a week, only to reappear with a flood of “I miss you” texts right after posting about a disappointing night out. It took me far too long to see that I wasn’t a person he was interested in. I was a tool he used to feel better about himself.

Are They Genuinely Undecided?

To be fair, sometimes people are just confused. They could be dating a few people at once, trying to figure out who’s the best fit. Or maybe they just ended a big relationship and are terrified of jumping back in. While this might sound a bit more excusable, the result for you is identical. Their indecision puts your emotional life on hold. An emotionally mature person would be upfront about their uncertainty. A bencher will just keep you dangling, hoping you’ll stick around until they’ve made up their mind.

Could It Be They Just Don’t Know How to End Things?

Let’s face it, breaking up sucks. It’s uncomfortable. It’s messy. And some people would rather do literally anything else than have a direct, honest conversation that might hurt someone’s feelings. For them, benching is a coward’s exit. A passive rejection. Instead of being the “bad guy,” they just slowly fade away, popping back in just often enough to keep the situation from having a clear ending. It’s a weak move that’s ultimately so much crueler than a clean break.

Could I Be Getting Benched Right Now? The Telltale Signs

When you really like someone, it’s easy to live in denial. You want to believe the best, so you make excuses for their behavior. They’re just busy with work. They’re not a big texter. But if you force yourself to look at the cold, hard patterns, the truth is usually staring you right in the face.

Is Their Communication All Over the Place?

This is the number one giveaway. The communication is a chaotic mess of extremes. One day, you’re locked in a marathon text session, feeling totally in sync. For the next five, you’re lucky if you get a one-word answer. It’s an emotional whiplash. This hot-and-cold routine is a manipulation tactic, whether they realize it or not. They give you a hit of connection that gets you hooked, then pull away, leaving you desperate for more.

I remember this guy, Mark. He was the king of being “slammed at work.” He’d come on strong for a day, making plans, making me feel like his top priority. Then, crickets. A week of absolute silence. Then, my phone would light up at midnight. “You up?” Classic bencher. He wasn’t interested in me. He was interested in the idea of me, available whenever he felt like it.

Do They Only Make Last-Minute Plans?

Does this sound familiar? It’s Friday night, and your phone is silent. You’ve accepted your fate of Netflix and takeout. Then, at 9:30 PM, you get the text: “What are you doing?” Spontaneity is one thing, but a steady diet of last-minute plans is a huge red flag. It means you’re their backup plan. You’re the person they hit up when their preferred plans fall through. You deserve someone who is excited to put you on their calendar, not someone who pencils you in when they have nothing better to do.

Are Your Conversations Stuck on the Surface?

Real connections are built on vulnerability. You talk about your dreams, your fears, your weird family traditions. With a bencher, the conversation never gets out of the shallow end. They’ll ask how your day was, but they won’t ask follow-up questions. They keep it light and superficial because going deeper requires an emotional investment they have no intention of making.

Do They Disappear and Then Reappear Like Nothing Happened?

This move has a name: “breadcrumbing.” They go completely MIA for days, even weeks. You grieve the connection, start to move on, and then—ping. They slide back into your life with a casual meme or a “hey stranger” as if no time has passed. There’s no apology, no explanation. In their mind, they did nothing wrong. They were just letting their option sit for a while. This cycle is incredibly damaging, yanking you back to square one just when you were starting to heal.

Are They Still Super Active on Dating Apps?

This one is painfully simple. If your friend sees them on Bumble, or you notice their Hinge profile has new pictures, they are actively looking for other people. It’s one thing not to delete your apps after a first date, but if you’ve been talking for months and they’re still swiping like their life depends on it, it’s because you’re just one name on a very long list.

I learned this one the hard way. After a month of talking to a guy I was really excited about, I paused my own profiles. One night, a friend sent me a screenshot. It was his profile. He’d updated it that day. My stomach just turned to ice. All the late-night calls and “can’t wait to see you” texts were a lie. I wasn’t the person he was choosing; I was just a person he was talking to while he searched for someone else.

Digital Benching: Is Social Media Making It Worse?

Oh, absolutely. Social media is the bencher’s playground. It allows them to keep you in their orbit with almost zero effort. They can watch every one of your Instagram stories. They can drop a fire emoji on a post. These are tiny digital breadcrumbs that create a false sense of connection. It costs them nothing, but it keeps your hope alive, making it that much harder to detach and move on.

What’s the Difference Between Taking It Slow and Straight-Up Benching?

This is where it gets tricky, because we can easily talk ourselves into believing a bencher is just “taking it slow.” But there’s a massive difference. Someone who is taking things slow is still moving forward. The key difference is consistency versus chaos.

Here’s a quick breakdown:

• Pace vs. Pattern: Taking it slow is about the speed of a relationship’s progression. Benching is a pattern of stopping and starting.
• Communication: A slow-mover is consistent. They might not text all day, but they don’t disappear for a week. A bencher is a ghost one day and a chatterbox the next.
• Intention: Someone taking it slow is usually willing to talk about it. They’ll say, “I really like you, I just need to move at my own pace.” A bencher will dodge any conversation about “what this is.”
• Progression: A slow relationship still grows. A benching situation is a hamster wheel. You’re putting in the effort but going nowhere.

How Does Benching Damage Your Mental Health?

Don’t underestimate the toll this takes. The constant uncertainty is a breeding ground for anxiety. You become obsessed with deciphering their mixed signals, replaying conversations in your head, and trying to figure out what you did wrong. As research from the University of Michigan shows, the brain processes social rejection in the same regions as physical pain. Being constantly treated like an afterthought is a form of chronic rejection, and it can do real damage to your confidence.

This experience can also poison your future relationships. You might start to think this emotional chaos is normal, or you could become overly clingy, terrified that a new partner will sideline you too. It can build a deep-seated fear of abandonment that makes it hard to ever feel safe and trust someone again.

I Think I’m Being Benched. What on Earth Do I Do Now?

The moment you realize you’re being benched is awful, but it’s also the moment you get your power back. It’s when you stop making excuses for them and start making choices for you. You have options, and none of them should involve waiting around for someone who treats you like a maybe.

Should I Confront Them About It?

A direct conversation can be terrifying, but it’s often the fastest path to the clarity you deserve. The goal isn’t to change them; it’s to get a straight answer so you can move on. A calm, simple text works best. “Hey, I’ve had a great time getting to know you, but the inconsistent communication has been confusing for me. I’m looking for something more consistent, so I wanted to see where your head is at.”

Their response tells you everything. An interested person will step up. A bencher will get defensive, give you a bunch of excuses, or just disappear. Either way, you have your answer.

How Do I Reclaim My Power and Self-Worth?

You reclaim your power the second you stop asking, “How can I get them to pick me?” and start asking, “Is this good enough for me?” The answer is a resounding no. You take your power back by remembering your value and refusing to settle for a role that minimizes it.

I had a crystal-clear turning point with a guy who had been stringing me along for weeks. My phone buzzed with his name after days of silence, and my first feeling wasn’t excitement. It was exhaustion. I was just so tired of the game. In that moment, something shifted. I put my phone on silent, put on a dress I loved, and went out with my friends. I didn’t text him back. Not that night, not ever. It wasn’t about revenge. It was about choosing my own peace over his chaos. I took myself off his bench.

Is It Ever Okay to Just Walk Away Without a Word?

Yes. 100%. While a mature conversation is great in theory, you don’t owe a lengthy explanation to someone who has repeatedly disrespected your time and feelings. Their actions have said it all. If a situation is causing you pain, you have every right to protect yourself by walking away. Block the number. Unfollow their accounts. Do what you need to do. Your absence is the most powerful message you can send.

How Can I Avoid Benching Someone Else (or Myself) in the Future?

Once you’ve felt the sting of being benched, you can use that experience to date with more integrity and intention. Breaking the cycle means being honest, first with yourself, and then with others.

Could Clear Communication Be the Antidote?

Communication that is clear, honest, and kind is the ultimate cure for benching. If you’re not feeling it with someone, be an adult and tell them. A simple, “I’ve enjoyed our time together, but I don’t feel a romantic spark,” is infinitely kinder than just fading away. If you’re the one who feels uncertain, say that! Being upfront protects everyone involved.

Why Is It So Important to Know What You Want?

When you don’t know what you want, you’ll accept anything. Take some real time to think about it. What are your non-negotiables? What does a healthy relationship actually feel like to you? When you have a clear destination in mind, you’ll stop getting on buses going in the wrong direction. You’ll get better at spotting red flags and more confident in walking away from situations that don’t serve you.

When Is It Time to Cut the Cord?

Trust that feeling in your stomach. If something feels wrong, it’s because it is. You don’t need a signed confession to know when a situation isn’t right for you. If someone consistently makes you feel confused, anxious, or bad about yourself, that is your sign to leave. Instead, look for the green flags that signal a healthy connection.

Look for these green flags in a potential partner:

• Consistency: Their words and actions are aligned.
• Clear Intentions: They’re not afraid to talk about what they’re looking for.
• Prioritization: They make time for you. You feel like a priority.
• Respect for Your Time: They make plans in advance and they stick to them.
• Emotional Availability: They’re interested in getting to know the real you, flaws and all.

Conclusion: You Are Not an Option

Dating today can feel like a minefield, and benching is one of the worst traps. It’s a tactic that thrives on your hope and their ambiguity, leaving you feeling disposable. But please, burn this into your brain: you are not an option. You are not a “maybe” to be activated when someone is bored. You are the whole damn thing.

Seeing the signs of benching is your first step. The next, and most important, is choosing yourself. Choose to walk away from anyone and anything that makes you feel small. Choose to pour your energy into the people and passions that fill you up. Take yourself off the bench and refuse to play the game. You deserve a spot in the starting lineup. Don’t let anyone make you forget it.

FAQ – Benching in Dating